Das Teichbachtal bei Gütenbach zeigt die waldreiche Landschaft des südlichen Schwarzwalds.
Photo: Dietmar Rabich via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Forest-covered mountains, meadow valleys, and higher hilltops give the Schwarzwald-Baar district its varied landscape setting. Added to this are smaller towns, spa-town character, and historic townscapes. For your family holiday, the question is therefore less about the “best” place than about the landscape and stay style you are looking for.
If you like being outdoors on holiday, you can already make the landscape part of your choice of location: Should the holiday apartment reflect more of the Black Forest’s wooded character, be located in a valley, or serve as a base for higher landscapes? A blanket classification of all places would not make sense here. What matters is the holiday mix of nature, town visits, and peace and quiet you imagine for your family.

The Schwarzwald-Baar district is not only something you experience through its landscape. In Villingen-Schwenningen, historic architecture, remains of the fortifications, the minster, and the Franciscan Museum offer cultural points of reference. This allows you to combine nature experiences with a day in town and a cultural outing instead of making every holiday day the same.
Regional traditions and local festivals are also part of the cultural setting of the Black Forest. You should check specific dates and specialities according to the travel period and chosen place. As a general travel timeframe, the Black Forest is enjoyed year-round; which season best suits your plans depends on your personal preferences.
For a concrete decision, two differently described location types are worth considering. Bad Dürrheim is associated with a spa area, proximity to the spa centre, and a quiet location in greenery. If you are looking for a rather peaceful base near a spa town, you can specifically look for a holiday apartment or holiday home there.
Brigachtal is a smaller municipality in the Brigach valley between Villingen and Donaueschingen. This can be interesting for families who want a smaller starting point with connections to both places. No specific travel times or transport advantages can be inferred from this.

When choosing accommodation, it is therefore worth first deciding on the desired impression of place and landscape. You can then compare the accommodation’s exact location, the town visits you plan, and your preferences for peace or culture. A broader comparison frame for other holiday regions in the federal state is provided by Baden-Württemberg.
These places also belong to the district’s range of towns and villages:
The district is located in southern Baden-Württemberg and, in the Black Forest context, is associated with wooded mountains, meadow valleys, and higher hilltops. You should check the exact character depending on the place.
Yes. The rural Black Forest landscape can be complemented by Villingen-Schwenningen with its historic architecture, remains of fortifications, the minster, and the Franciscan Museum.
Bad Dürrheim is described as a quiet, green location near a spa town; Brigachtal as a smaller municipality in the Brigach valley between Villingen and Donaueschingen. The choice depends on the kind of place and excursion style you want.